The Secret Society of Buzz
Tue, Mar 11, 2008
Many aspiring social marketers are surprised when they stumble into a community of IMers who are secretly buzzing (promoting) each others content.
The Secret
These covert little communities are simple vote sharing networks and generally work like this:
Each member is allowed to submit a predefined number of URLs (usually per week or per month) and request that it be “dugg”, “stumbled”, “bookmarked”, etc. on selected social media sites.
The submissions typically arrive via email to each member of that community.
Each member of the group then chooses to either delete that request or follow through and “buzz” their fellow member’s post or article.
Obviously, if your an honest buzzer, you are going to be graciously responding to many more requests than you submit.
The Math
If you do the math on this type of group voting structure it gets kind of interesting.
For example:
Group members = 100
Allowed request per day = 1
Average requests per group per day = 50 (not everyone makes a request everyday)
Number of email requests you get = 50
My experience with a few of these groups shows that typically, only the folks who consistently submit requests respond to others requests. This usually fits into the 80/20 rule, so only 20% of the members are really active buzzers. However, even these ladies and gentlemen do not buzz EVERY request, they only buzz content that they like AND have time for. This translates into about a 10 per day MAX or 20%.
So, plugging in these numbers, we can finish the calculation:
Number of consistent requesters = 20
Number of votes you get on your one request = 4
So, theoretically, on average you get about 4 votes for your 10.
The Verdict
Is it worth your time?
I say YES, but with a BIG caution.
Yes because 4 votes are more than you might get if you don’t join a buzz group. And… four well timed votes are all you need to get into the mainstream, and possibly the “jet stream”, on some social media sites and attract the attention of the average social media crowd looking for content that looks like it’s on the rise.
Caution because the numbers above are true for new buzz groups only. Why? Because inevitably a load of social marketing barnacles find established buzz groups and do nothing but make requests.
I have seen some of these guys leeching from multiple buzz groups, requesting buzz favors on the same content and never returning the favor or being part of the community.
So, unless there is an active buzz group admin that is seriously checking the activity of anyone who makes requests, the group is doomed to failure.
The other thing that tends to happen is the group gets so large that everyone’s Inbox fills up with requests each night and the active participants spend the first 30 minutes of the day deleting most and buzzing about 10.
So, I would also suggest trying to find a “closed” buzz group through a friend or forum. This type of group is more sustainable and efficient for the reasons stated above.
The Buzz Groups
I will be keeping my 2 little buzz groups to myself because they are humming along quite nicely for now. However, if you are interested in joining or inviting Web2Center readers to a buzz group, feel free to do so in the comments.
If you have some insight into the secret society of buzzers, please share your thoughts with us as well!
Related Posts From Other Great Blogs
5 Tips For Planning A Social Media Marketing Campaign
Social Media Marketing is Branding
Social Media Marketing - What is it and What is it Good For?
Live from SMX: Tips on Social Media Marketing
Tags: blogging, Social Marketing









March 12th, 2008 at 2:55 pm
Hey buddy -
I wanted you to know that you earned a great big fat STUMBLE from me!
I’m always looking for comments on my blog - and I have the comment Luv tag turned on - so pop by when you get a chance.
Great article that puts this whole “I stumbled 50 times for others and only got 4″ into perspective.
Rick Butts
March 12th, 2008 at 4:06 pm
Hard to keep a group “secret” on a blog, dontcha think?.
I love the people I stay in touch with and I learn so much from their articles. It really expands my horizons beyond where I would normally venture. I derive a lot of satisfaction from doing what I said I would do - check out other people’s articles.
Works for me!
March 12th, 2008 at 4:59 pm
Great Post.
I live in the Caribbean and when we find “barnacles” we scrape them off.
The same should apply to the barnacles mentioned above.
One thing I do want to point out is that if, in my opinion, a post is a terrible post I won’t stumble it there has to be at least little something that I find amusing, entertaining, educational or just weird enogh to catch my fancy.
This one gets a definite thumbs up!
Randy The Hermit
March 12th, 2008 at 9:13 pm
LOL yeah,
I can easily relate on this. One more nuisance is when somebody either new to the game or just wired that way start trying to fix the things, and flood the group with emails requesting others to obey group discipline… At that point I usually flee
Misha
Mapquest Road Maps
March 13th, 2008 at 1:46 pm
@Brennan - Good point… it is hard to keep a good buzz group secret. You happen to belong to one of my two “secret” buzz groups. I won’t tell if you don’t
I also agree about connecting with the group.. I like keeping up with particular buzz group colleagues as I read the posts I vote for too.
@Randy - Thanks for the compliment.
@Misha - Yes, I failed to mention the self-appointed “buzz group cop” that each group will inevitably acquire. Thanks for bringing it up…
Tom
March 19th, 2008 at 11:51 am
Would love to join your groups - and will add that I’ll keep it confidential!